You may have seen the recent controversial TV ad run by Barnardos, depicting scenes of violence and drug abuse. Despite complaints from the public calling for the advert to be taken off the air, the Advertising Standards Authority has allowed the advert to stand.
The official figures from the ASA show that 48 viewers has challenged whether the ad should be shown when large numbers of children may be watching, while 29 viewers – some of whom who had been reported of having been abused as children themselves questioned that the ad could cause serious distress.
The ASA allowed the advert to continue, by making the crucial distinction that the scenes may inappropriate for other adverts, but are justifiable in the context of a charity campaign such as this. If you have been offended by any form of advert, or believe a promotion to be untruthful then the you can register your complaint here.
It isn’t the first time the charity has caused controversy with their adverts. This time in 2003 they ran an advert with images of babies with syringes and cockroaches in their mouths. This shocking campaign soon got taken off the air. I respect the creative minds behind these adverts and the message they are trying to send, however I don’t think they should have the right to offend many members of the public. Work like this could make a great video installation piece for a gallery – I would perhaps even pay to see it. But in the context of a public broadcast, I believe it to be inappropriate.
It is certainly an interesting debate on where the boundaries of advertising and marketing lie. In my normally liberal opinion, having seen the advert (while I was having dinner) I don’t think it should be aired before the watershed. It will be adults who will be most likely potentially donating to the charity in any case. I resent the fact that we are helplessly exposed to offensive adverts, which are becoming more and more shocking. However with most of these shocking adverts promoting a good cause, what is to be deemed acceptable seems something of a grey area.